How CPG Brands Can Turn Social Media Into Real Growth With Jessyca Dewey

Jessyca Dewey
Jessyca Dewey

Jessyca Dewey is the Founder of The Y Collective, a social-first marketing agency specializing in purpose-driven, better-for-you CPG brands. With over 16 years in digital marketing, she helps brands connect content, paid and organic social, and influencer strategy to measurable growth and retail results. Jessyca’s background includes VaynerMedia and Califia Farms, along with Webby and Shorty Award-winning work for L’Oréal. Raised in Central California, her approach is shaped by an early connection to agriculture, food equity, and authentic storytelling.

Apple
Spotify
amazon music

Here’s a glimpse of what you’ll learn: 

  • [2:19] Jessyca Dewey’s path from agriculture to CPG marketing
  • [8:20] How Jessyca balances creativity and performance in content strategy
  • [12:53] What CPG brands should focus on when measuring the impact of social media
  • [15:41] Connecting social strategy to retail growth and the customer journey
  • [18:25] Why sustainable brand growth matters more than chasing viral moments
  • [26:41] Jessyca’s approach to bringing paid and organic social together
  • [32:05] Using AI thoughtfully while keeping human creativity at the center of content
  • [36:23] The growing importance of trust, authenticity, and real-world brand experiences
  • [40:57] Jessyca’s vision for stronger creator communities and collaborative content creation

In this episode…

Social media can generate attention, but attention alone does not drive CPG growth. The real opportunity is connecting content to brand recall, retail performance, and long-term momentum. So how can brands move beyond followers and viral moments to make social media work harder for the business?

Jessyca Dewey, a seasoned digital marketing and social media strategist, believes the answer starts with focusing on sustained, meaningful growth rather than vanity metrics or one-off wins. Brands should create content with a clear strategic purpose, learn from what performs, and use those insights across both paid and organic social. Jessyca also emphasizes making retail messaging memorable, repurposing strong creative, and using AI as a tool without losing the human storytelling and authenticity consumers respond to. Ultimately, effective social strategy connects creativity, performance, and the customer journey to support real business growth.

In this episode of The Missing Ingredient, CJ Bruce sits down with Jessyca Dewey, Founder of The Y Collective, to discuss turning social media into real CPG growth. Jessyca shares how to measure meaningful results, connect paid and organic social, and build sustainable momentum beyond viral hits. She also explores AI, authentic storytelling, and the growing value of real-world content.

Resources mentioned in this episode:

Quotable Moments:

  • “It’s really important to put all content trends through a filter.”
  • “The goal of going viral … is not to go viral.”
  • “Why was the highest-performing paid content not being used in organic in some way, shape, or form?”
  • “Presumably, the audience for paid is essentially the audience that we want for organic.”
  • “You have to be really careful to the metrics and what the audience is telling you that they want to hear.”

Action Steps:

  1. Filter every social trend through your brand strategy: Evaluating whether a trend fits your message, timing, and objectives prevents short-term engagement from diluting more important campaigns.
  2. Connect social content to retail behavior: Showing consumers where to find your product and giving them a memorable reason to look for it can help turn awareness into purchases.
  3. Create a feedback loop between paid and organic content: Testing successful ideas across both channels helps brands learn what resonates while getting more value from limited creative budgets.
  4. Build on viral content instead of treating it as a one-time win: Quickly creating follow-up posts, branded variations, and video replies can extend momentum and keep the brand connected to the conversation.
  5. Use AI to support human creativity, not replace it: Applying AI thoughtfully to workflows and selective creative tasks helps preserve the trust, authenticity, and human storytelling audiences respond to.

Sponsor for this episode…

This episode is sponsored by The Missing Ingredient, a food and beverage marketing agency that believes a better future starts with food. They partner with purpose-driven brands to drive growth through smart, results-focused marketing — without the “set it and forget it” approach. 

From brand awareness and paid media to content, influencer partnerships, and loyalty programs, they act as true strategic partners invested in your long-term success. 

To learn more about how they help food and beverage brands grow with impact, visit themissingingredient.com today.

Powered by Rise25 Podcast Production Company

Full Transcript

Introduction and Guest Background

Intro: 00:01

Welcome to The Missing Ingredient podcast with CJ Bruce, where food and beverage founders, operators and experts share the real strategies behind building successful brands. Let’s jump into today’s show.

CJ Bruce: 00:15

Hey, I’m CJ Bruce and welcome to the show. This is the podcast where founders and leaders of high impact food and beverage brands who are serious about scaling. Each episode, I sit down with the people who power the food and beverage industry, brand operators, agencies, vendors, and creators to uncomplicate the strategies that take brands from early traction to serious scale.

This episode is sponsored by The Missing Ingredient, a food and beverage marketing agency with over a decade in the industry. We take a different approach, starting with your business goals, looking at the full picture and building a marketing strategy that actually ties back to growth from content and performance marketing to influencer partnerships and AI powered workflows. We’re an extension of your team, not just another vendor. Learn more at themissingingredient.com. 

Now, before I introduce today’s guest, I want to give a big thank you to Jake Ollis. You can check out his website at. We are memorial.com, and he specializes in helping food and beverage brands build a strong brand narrative and turn that into high performing creative across channels. He introduced us to today’s guest.

So today’s guest is Jessyca Dewey. She’s the Founder of Y Collective, a social first agency for purpose driven. Better for you CPG brands with 16 years in content and digital marketing across demand media, VaynerMedia and brands including L’Oreal, Hasbro and Califia Farms. At VaynerMedia, she helped open the LA office and led them to the Webby and Shorty Awards for L’Oreal. Experience she now brings to emerging brands that need senior strategy without a holding company structure. Her philosophy is simple most agencies build tract homes, swapping a client’s name into someone else’s blueprint, while the Y Collective builds homes with character or strategy. Social and performance are designed together from the studs up. Welcome to the show, Jessyca.

Jessyca Dewey: 01:50

Hey CJ. Thanks so much for having me. And like you said, shout out to Jake for mentioning my name to be a guest on The Missing Ingredient podcast.

CJ Bruce: 02:00

Happy to have you here. Okay, so let’s start with your background. You grew up in Central California and you saw, you know, agriculture inequities up close. Farm to table meals. I’m curious what moment turned that upbringing into the filter on?

You know, what brands that you really want to work with today and the work that you do today?

Jessyca Dewey: 02:19

Sure. So, you know, I’m really inspired by the work that the painter Lin sisters are doing. And it always reminds me of some of my aspirations from when I was a kid. I was born, as we just chatted about, because you’re in the Sacramento area as well. I was born in Sacramento, and then when I was ten, we moved to a town called Kingsburg, California, which is in Fresno County.

It’s about 11,000 people, and the entire economy is built around agriculture. It’s really actually it’s the number one stone. Stone fruit producing region in the world over Georgia by a long shot. Most people don’t actually know that. And I grew up across the street from a farm. 

 And also my mom grew up on a dairy farm, so growing up, I spent all a lot of my time at my grandma on her farm with my grandma on her farm, and she had a big thriving garden. And they didn’t have any cattle or dairy cows when I was growing up. By that time, they had sold off all of the animals. But I grew up hearing all of these stories of what traditional dairy farms and farming looked like. They grew cotton one year, and then they grew alfalfa to replenish the soil the next year. 

 Right? And so I learned early on some of these cycles and the treatment of animals and how traditional farming back in like the 1950s looked. Fast forward. I moved to Los Angeles, I oh, and also going back to if we want to close the loop on the inequities, right, the economy of the Central Valley Looks like people who are rich farmers. Usually there’s not. 

 There’s a lot of not rich farmers, but there are also a lot of rich ones. They’re at the top of the food chain in Kingsburg. And then there’s a lot of farm workers, right? And there’s just a food desert inequality there. The farmers markets in LA and access to fresh produce and fresh vegetables, for example, is a lot more prolific in LA than it is right where the food is grown. 

 And so when I moved to LA, I started to see a lot of that inequity. And it exists everywhere, right? But it was just really fascinating to be like, wow, the farmers markets and the access to fresh, high quality produce is so much better in LA. And I get that it’s not accessible here either. Depending on your income levels. 

 And so that really kind of started grinding my gears a little bit. And then, you know, you start learning about the food systems and how dairy farms or dairies look today. Dairies look a lot different than they did when my mom was growing up, and not in a good way. So I became really interested in following along with that story and some of the inequities there. I moved to LA, I got a journalism degree. 

 I moved into marketing in the beauty space. I worked with L’Oreal. And like you mentioned earlier, I was one of the first 11 members to start VaynerMedia LA with Gary Vee or Gary Vaynerchuk, and I was fully dedicated to L’Oreal account at the time, and I was in my 20s. So talking a lot about different eyeshadows and the way the mascara works and the trends in lipstick, colors and skincare was really exciting at the time. It was creatively really fulfilling, and I got to have a lot of fun, come up with really cool creative work with different photographers, videographers, influencers. 

 But it didn’t have a long standing. Vision or mission behind it, right? Some could argue that you’re making the world better by focusing on beauty, and I think that there is some merit to that. But it, largely speaking, didn’t have enough weight for me. I moved into ad tech and focused on the content strategy for a few ad tech companies, and then I kind of hit a little bit of a bottom in the sense that I was pretty miserable in the types of content I was creating. 

 I was creating content at scale. I was leading a team of eight people to create about a thousand internet quizzes a day. And while it’s incredibly profitable and the data and the analysis behind what makes those work was really exciting to me and a challenge to me. It didn’t have any mission to it. So I went to work at Califia Farms, and that was during this point where I was like, you know, this kind of brings all of those story points together for me. 

 And I led social media and influencer marketing at Califia and really got to like focus in on ways that the food system can impact the world in ways that it does and ways that we can do a better job. And that was when I got the idea to start the Y Collective, which is a people first social media agency, where we really want to tell those stories and follow the trends for a select few brands that are lucky enough to work with us and that we’re lucky enough to work with, and five years later, here we are with a thriving team and great clients and really working to expand shelf life. I’m sorry. Shelf space for all of our clients across the board, and we’re excited to do it.

Scaling Content Without Losing Brand Strategy

CJ Bruce: 07:56

Awesome. That’s awesome. Appreciate that background. I’m curious going into the end of the content piece. So you’re doing content at scale and then doing more thoughtful storytelling.

Are there, you know, are there learnings from that content at scale that you still bring into the content that you produce today? Or are you kind of like, scrap that and it’s just not the right approach and, you know, more focused, thoughtful content or how do you merge those? Or how does that kind of come up in the work today?

Jessyca Dewey: 08:20

Sure. I appreciate you asking that. I think it’s really interesting. I was thinking about it yesterday, actually just off the top of my head, because I really did get my start in content at scale. I worked at Demand Media, which then became Leaf Group, which if anybody remembers livestrong.com or ehow.com, I was one of the early content members of that team, and that was in 2009.

It was quite a time. And one of a few of the things that we learned were how to look at content in a way that starts with the performance and to create content at scale based on how we can analyze and guess the performance of that piece of content. And that helps inform the worth of that content, right? So if, if I am able to look and say this category of content, so whether it’s 20 pieces of content or 303,000, I can look at it and say, I can estimate the general worth of it, and I can create the content based on what that worth is. So I know that this piece of content is probably worth $20, and this piece of content is probably worth $200. 

 Because if we look at the cycle of the content all the way, we used to call an internal rate of return IRR, we’d be able to assess what pieces of content should move forward. And so with the Y Collective, we kind of do bring in a lot of the learnings from my, let’s call it a decade of scaling content at massive, kind of previously unheard of scale, because we’re always thinking about it in this filter of like, what is it worth? How can we spin off different aspects of it? So for example, I don’t, I’m not our best content creator, but I do a lot of it. I enjoy it, it gives me it brings me a lot of joy. 

 And yesterday I made an egg salad using a little bit of a hack for one of our brands. I made it for my lunch and I used one brand in the egg salad. It’s Dorot Gardens. It’s a frozen herb and garlic and onion product that you can find in most grocery stores in the frozen veggie section. I use that product in there. 

 And then I thought, well, we have a tahini brand that we could probably use in there and make it a separate video and then I could, instead of putting it on a piece of bread. The third video could just be me putting it on a cracker. Now, does that align with each of those brand’s strategies and objectives? Maybe not. So we need to put those through that filter, right? 

 Like we are telling stories specific to each brand, not just coming up with content at scale, but a little extra added value content never hurt anyone. And so that’s one way that we also bring in that content at scale mindset of like, how can we make this into as many different things? Another big learning from my time at At Demand Media was that when you, when something really hit, you look at ways to make that continue to work for you. So we have a beverage brand, it’s an alcohol brand. We did a mock or I’m sorry, a mimosa style beverage. 

 We saw that that really, really worked on paid media. So instead of using orange juice for that mimosa, we did one with watermelon juice. We did one with beet juice, right. And that may get tiresome. You have to be really careful to the metrics and what the audience is telling you that they want to hear. 

 But that’s another way that we’ve learned that we’ve brought in some of those content at scale, at scale stories, and into the way that we operate today.

CJ Bruce: 12:14

Yeah, those are great, great takeaways. I want to continue on the thread of, you know, measurement and metrics. So we’ve talked in the past about follower growth being kind of a vanity metrics, even though of course often still ask for it. Yeah. And so you know what ultimately matters, especially brands selling at retail, you know, retail velocity.

And like you said, moving it off the shelf. So I’m curious about how you, you know, how do you two questions here. One is, you know, when brands come and say, hey, we want follower growth. You know, how do you have that conversation? Kind of guide them in the direction of what metrics actually matter? 

 And the second part is how do you actually. How do you measure that? You know, your focus on social. How do you measure that? It’s actually impacting sales at shelf.

Jessyca Dewey: 12:53

Sure. So I think that let’s talk about that in a couple of ways. It’s a great question. Number one, clients are only as teachable as they want to be. And so we teach them as much as they want us to teach them.

We’re happy to do so. And there is a certain value still to growing follower count. We are seeing that, you know, I’m sure you’ve probably read Instagram. Seems like they’re hinting at potentially showcasing views or reach on profiles rather than just showcasing followers. So that’s a really interesting read. 

 It’s kind of taking a note from TikTok. What we do see is that follower growth still indicates to people who are not social media experts, that the brand is succeeding in growing an audience and owned audience, even though it’s not particularly an owned audience. But let’s just call it that for now. We know that buyers are still looking at Instagram followers, and we know that investors are still looking at Instagram followers. So it only makes sense that a lot of C-suite leaders at CPG brands are still looking at followers, and we’re happy to grow that. 

 I think there is value there. It just doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s translating to sales on shelf. And so we’re always in the business of trying to make that clear. I think one of the general struggles of people in working in social is making sure leadership understands that there is a lack of attribution for in-person real life velocity and social media success. And we just kind of have to trust the process. 

 I know there’s different ways we work. We do a lot of paid as well. There’s ways that we can kind of attribute paid reach and impressions to shelf. But oftentimes it’s just proving outreach, proving out engagement, making sure that the right people are seeing the right content and the right zip codes, and then watching the numbers and spins increase as a result and trying to tie those two together. Isn’t that kind of what you experience as well?

CJ Bruce: 15:07

Yeah, yeah, definitely finding those, you know, like corollary metrics of, okay, are people in the market where we’re selling the product products available? Are they seeing the ads or are they seeing the posts? Are they engaging with those posts as much as possible? And then like you said, thinking about ways to think about it holistically, not just from the consumer, but also supporting retail or showing literally showing people where they can go in the store to buy the product on social, right, as ways to help connect those dots. So yeah, I think very definitely similar approaches and philosophy around that.

Making Retail Messaging Memorable

Jessyca Dewey: 15:41

Yeah. I mean, not only do we really try to educate the consumer as to where the product is, but we try to do it in a way that’s sticky. So bringing themes and messaging together, like we, we, for example, did this 360 campaign last year for the brand that I mentioned, Royal Gardens. They have eight different SKUs, but like most people know them for their garlic, their onions and their ginger in the frozen vegetable section. And they’re kind of a category disruptor right there.

They’re alone. Most other options are either fresh herbs or like the squeeze bottles or anything that aren’t as fresh. And so it’s about telling people where to find them in the frozen section, but also what stores to find them in and why to look for them in the first place. And so I think, you know, we came up with this campaign called Make a Note to Grab Your Coat, and we did a cable commercial for it, a New York Times, Times Square billboard. We did a bunch of social content and kind of brought it into this idea of like, it’s in the freezer and you have to write down to make a note to grab it because it is so much more easy than using. 

 Chopping your own garlic and herbs, right? But you have to remember to get it because it’s not. So the whole campaign was about making the grocery list that says Dorot Gardens. And we you need that tie in because most people are just going to grab garlic, and then they’re gonna regret all their life choices because it adds ten minutes to meal prep unnecessarily. So those are the strategic ways that we try to think through, like where, where is the missing part or the missing ingredient? 

 And how can we, how can we fill in that story and make sure that people know where to find the product that they’re looking for?

CJ Bruce: 17:33

Yeah, it’s a great explanation there. And just how do you connect the storytelling to what the customer journey is to, you know, know about the product, think about it, purchase it, use it again and again. Yeah, it makes a lot of sense. I want to shift into the so things going viral on social. So it does happen sometimes.

Yeah. You can’t control at all. But when something I think and feel free to, you know, correct. Or, or dig into any of the pre-show research that I pulled on this. Oh, there was a fridge bean dip from Biena.

Jessyca Dewey: 18:04

Oh, yeah. We can talk about that.

CJ Bruce: 18:06

24 million plus. And so curious what happened there that helped to drive that. And then also kind of connecting what we were just talking about after that happens, what do you do post viral hit? How do you capture some of that? Or is it kind of it’s it’s one and done and you continue on posting or how do you think about that integration post viral hit?

Turning a Viral Hit Into Sustained Brand Momentum

Jessyca Dewey: 18:25

Yeah, that was what a time. Okay, so I would be remiss to not start by emphasizing that we as social experts are chasing, talking to the audience and not chasing the algorithm. Right? So first things first, educating and getting the message out. I’m sure you can agree that the goal of going viral, the goal is not to go viral.

The goal is consistent, sustained, meaningful growth for your brand, that people learn about it from the top of funnel and then remember it, remember it, remember it, think, oh, I must have that march their butts into target and buy it off of the shelf or hit click. If it’s an e-com play, right? It is not to be remembered for a one hit wonder. Also, while we’re at it, CJ, I can’t I would be mistaken if I did not mention that we as the at the Y Collective and I imagine that TMI does it as well. We emphasize to our clients that it’s really important to put all content trends through a filter. 

 Does this match the brand? Are we doing it fast enough so that we can be at the top of it. We. And does it really do something that fulfills our strategy? Right. 

 We had we saw the I mean, by the time this goes live, no one will remember this anyway. But for the sake of this conversation, we know that last week the proposal in New York went viral. Right? It was the people who climbed Empire State Building proposed, had the flag. And immediately a bunch of brands were posting. 

 And sure, it probably did really well for a bunch of those brands. I’ve had a lot of posts in my career that were capitalizing on those moments, have a lot of success in terms of performance as well. But let’s define performance. Did it stand out? Do you? 

 Let me ask you, did do you remember any of the messages that you saw on those last week?

CJ Bruce: 20:37

No. Yeah. Nothing stood out. Yeah.

Jessyca Dewey: 20:40

What’s your bet? Do you think consumers did know? Okay. All right. So we were in the middle of of teasing a new product launch.

And we for one of our clients and we thought, well, this otherwise might fit, but we have a plan in place for teasing this, this product launch. And if we hop on this, it’s going to dilute the message that we’re otherwise trying to get across for this brand. And, and to what avail? Like, yes, the likes might be higher because everybody’s amped on how incredible this proposal was. It’s funny, it’s crazy. 

 It’s unhinged. But what is it really doing for the brand in the long run? And so that’s the filter that we’re always putting things on when things are going viral. Now, to answer your original question. Yeah. 

 So let’s see. I guess it was 2024 and one of our fantastic clients, we no longer work with them, but they are gems. It’s a fantastic brand and in there. They’re spreading quickly and we love being a part of their story. Biena Snacks. 

 Biena Snacks. At the time was really focused on their tasty, thin dippable chips. They’re a volume eating play you can eat. I believe 45 of the chips in one serving. For a low calorie amount, they’re made out of vegetables. 

 Vegetables are the main ingredient. Fantastic product. And we had really been pushing the envelope in moving away from really just aesthetic recipe content. And so for Cinco de Mayo, we saw, you know, I have to give credit. One of the we saw an influencer did a video on a fridge drawer of tiramisu. 

 And we thought, well, that would be kind of crazy to do a seven layer bean dip to top it. And so for Cinco de Mayo we. I actually, because none of our creators wanted to turn their entire fridge into a slop drawer for a seven layer bean dip. Spent an afternoon building a massive seven layer bean dip and it went viral. I mean, like it went mega viral. 

 It got like 50 in the long run. It got like 50 million likes. A few hundred million views. It was mega viral. Like there was a period of time for two, 2 or 3 days where I could say, yeah, my hand is going viral. 

 Did you see that fridge bean dip? And it was about a 50% chance that people would say, oh yeah, I did see that, right? Really cool. It would not have gone viral if it were heavily branded and it would not have gone viral, I believe, if it were not seasonally focused, right? It went live on Cinco de Mayo. 

 And I think those two factors really played into the mega virality of that. Now, this is why brands shouldn’t seek virality. It’s always great. You can get earned media if you go mega viral and Biena did, you can you know, you can play off of the coattails of that virality, which we certainly did, and which I can talk about in a minute. But Biena, what was the long term big success of that win? 

 Well, they got like 2000 new followers, maybe three, I can’t remember exactly. Again, it was a couple years ago, but like commensurate with the level of success of the video, the way that the algorithm works is if something goes mega viral, you don’t actually get a ton more followers necessarily. Yeah, they Biena didn’t have a paid media budget, so there wasn’t a way to totally amplify that message beyond the one single hit. So that was something that we had to work in terms of a constraint. But the things that we did do, and these are actionable for brands that have gone viral. 

 If a brand has gone viral and a lot of times it’s the videos, you never know. I mean, you probably have seen this yourself. It’s the videos you never think are going to go viral that go viral. Maybe you have an inkling, but, you know, oftentimes you have an inkling. And then those are the ones that really tank. 

 So it’s best just to not not think about it much. But we thought of more ways to bring in the fridge, dip to Biena and make it more branded. So we had a, we immediately we had like a war room that weekend where we brought in a bunch of other creators to make additional bean dips and joke about it in a variety of ways. We use the reply video feature and replied to a lot of the comments. So people were like, oh. 

 That looks incredible. We’d reply to it if they came up with a funny comment, we’d do a video reply to it so that for a couple of weeks, the entire feed was about Biena bean dip, so that we were really carefully getting those, the brand word, the brand name in there, as well as the bean dip, so that as it surfaced and people were searching for it and people were playing off of the success that they were continuing to have a, a flywheel effect. And, Biena was able to successfully ride that in terms of organic performance for about a month. And that was a really cool takeaway.

Connecting Paid and Organic Social

CJ Bruce: 26:14

That was cool. Yeah, that’s a great takeaway. We’ve talked a few times about paid, paid and organic and I know, yeah, on your website, you talk, you say, you know, a line of who decided paid social shouldn’t talk to organic social anyway. Yeah. And so I think this is something we talk about a lot too.

And just I’m curious your thoughts on, you know, how paid and organic work together for the Y Collective and how you think about that as an approach and how you approach it with your clients.

Jessyca Dewey: 26:41

You know, when I was at Califia Farms, we had a paid agency and I was running organic and I was running or like working with the paid agency, we had a contractor that actually works with Y Collective now, who was, who was running it as a consultant at the time, but we were working hand in hand and we had a very curated content calendar for the organic feed. And this was right when reels came out on Instagram. So keep that in mind. And what I noticed was that the content calendar for organic, when I first started the role was not any of the content from paid and, and vice versa, right? Both were doing great and were performing well, but the messaging didn’t align.

And coming from a content at scale background, I saw that as a missed opportunity. Why was the highest performing paid content not being used in organic in some way, shape or form? Not always, but with a filter. Right. And why was the organic content never being used and paid? 

 And often you still see that disconnect today. And so while it’s less groundbreaking now, as a philosophy, we’re really always looking to have efficiencies and cost efficiencies for our clients. A lot of our clients are working on really small budgets. CPG is known for its tight margins and its small budgets. And unless you’ve done a really, really large fundraise or have been in 10,000 doors for longer than a couple of years, you probably aren’t spending ten, $20,000 on just ad creative and different variations per month. 

 And as you know, with paid media, the more creative, the better, right? The more creative you can throw at the algorithm, the better. So we came up with this philosophy of cross Posting both paid and organic creative as much as possible. Repurposing whatever has been created as organic, turning it into paid testing, and using that as a feedback loop. Presumably, the audience for paid is essentially the audience that we want for organic. 

 There’s a few differences, right? Like where they are in the funnel. But for the most part, when we build an audience on paid media, that’s the audience that we ideally want for the brand across the board, the content that works for both. While the objectives may be slightly different, is going to resonate across the board. So we use this philosophy of testing and managing so that we can use it as a feedback loop all all across both of them.

CJ Bruce: 29:15

And you say go both ways. You mentioned that at the top that you’re posting it organically and say, you know, you see something that works well organically. Okay, we should run this into paid or sometime also the opposite of like, if you have a, you know, a suite of paid ads that you’re running, and then something works. Well, there it goes back into organic.

Jessyca Dewey: 29:32

Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. And we also think we also see that the concepts can work as well. So maybe if it was created as an ad, it’s going to feel a little bit too much like an ad to work on organic. But why did it work on the ad?

Is it the bright colors? Like we, we had one example. Actually, I have not to do too much product placement, but I really am thirsty. Yeah. Wonder Juice is one of our clients. 

 The watermelon is great for hydration and I’ve been drinking too much coffee. And you know, you see the bottle is really bright. And one of the best performing ads was at one point, an organic social post of the bottle being held in a brightly colored what looks like a convenience store aisle. And because the bottle is so bright and the colors around it are so bright, That ad has performed consistently through over the last year really, which is kind of incredible for ad ad fatigue, right? Or creative fatigue. 

 And so we’ve done a lot of tests. And one of the things that we’ve figured out is that the, the, the bottle in an aisle at the grocery store, the brightness of the bottle, brightness of an outfit, brightness of the background, that’s what performs. So then we try to bring that into the organic feed as well. Even though that one piece of content has kind of already run its course on organic, if that makes sense.

CJ Bruce: 31:01

Yeah, it makes total sense. I think that’s a great, you know, digging into those details of what actually makes it work. And then how do you translate that to the different ways that people might be experiencing, whether it’s paid or organic, I think is a really great, I think going back to your, you know, the content efficiencies, just thinking through that, I think is really helpful for brands to, you know, think about like, you don’t need to create all this extra stuff for all these extra channels. You can repurpose it. It can serve multiple needs.

Using AI Without Losing Human Storytelling

Jessyca Dewey: 31:32

Yeah.

CJ Bruce: 31:32

I want to shift into AI. So we have to talk about AI.

Jessyca Dewey: 31:38

Of course. Of course.

CJ Bruce: 31:40

So there’s, you know, some parallels here to its previous content at scale. Obviously now AI is making content at scale. Unfortunately, it’s super easy for people to just churn out garbage, not all garbage. You can, you know, there are ways to use it in the right way. And so I’m curious for you, you know, how do you think about using these tools, whether it’s with content or workflows while still preserving that core storytelling function?

Jessyca Dewey: 32:05

Sure. So to start off, I got my start in SEO content marketing, right? That was what Demand Media was in 2009, like I mentioned. And at the time, everybody was like, SEO is ruining everything. the quality socks.

And yes, it did write the eHow content sucked and everything kind of balanced out eventually, right? Google caught on to the fact that the consumer really didn’t want to be reading a bunch of SEO slop, and forced people who were writing for SEO to start writing better content with images and longer content with real thought leadership. And they really put a lot of quality measures into things. So now when you see something that performed in SEO, most of the time it’s a pretty decent piece. It’s maybe not a really artfully written piece. 

 Remember, I have a journalism background, but it is a high quality, meaningful one with sources like Google makes you source things, etc.. Right. And so I kind of feel the same way about AI. I think that there is going to be, and there currently is a consumer backlash for AI written copy and content. We do see that whenever we post something that is not thoughtfully produced by AI, and I can get into that in a minute that the consumer doesn’t like it. 

 We’ve posted what I would consider to be some thoughtless AI slop sort of to test. And it takes it takes consistently. It takes immediately. Nobody likes it. Now, occasionally we’ll use gen AI. 

 For example, if the backdrop, the if the branding of one of the brands is like purple and we want to bring some elements of purple, we use gen AI to alter an image to bring some of those branding elements in. And that’s subtle. And it’s also not something that we would have necessarily produced. And so ethically, as somebody who’s supporting is here to support people, we have the word collective in our name because we’re people first as an agency that seems to perform okay. And to me doesn’t have any ethical concerns. 

 But we do use AI. We use AI for our a lot of our processes internally, we’re looking into how to use AI in a more thoughtful way to catalog content. What we see a lot is that brands come to us with a library of content that is not cataloged in a way that makes it useful for them. And we see these as evergreen assets, right? Content is an asset. 

 Once you have it, it works. It can continue to work for you. If you posted it once, 3 or 4 months ago, you can post it again with a different hook and different audio, like go for it. So there’s all these, there’s different smart ways that we can use AI. And ultimately we see that people, and I believe that people are going to swing back and the quality measures will come into place that emphasizes people over machines in the particular instance of art and content, because it is its art and people can tell that it doesn’t have soul. 

 And so yeah, there’s cheaper, easier ways to do things. But if it doesn’t perform, then what good is it? And I think that we’re going to see that play out over the next couple of years and already are in a lot of ways.

CJ Bruce: 35:45

Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it’s great points and and the, you know, there are there’s a right way to use it or a good way to use it, right. Integrate it and be thoughtful about it. And I think that’s, you know, framing of really as a tool, right. It doesn’t replace everything.

And I think another thing we’ve seen on the, you know, on the, the art side of it is also people, especially if it’s something really creative, like I’d like to know that there was a person behind it, right? Like what was that person’s story? How did they come up with that? And how does that connect to whatever you’re trying to communicate? Or obviously, if it’s just done with AI fully, then you don’t have that. 

 And that kind of takes Teaser where it takes some of the soul out of it for sure.

Trust, Authenticity, and the Return to Real-Life Content

Jessyca Dewey: 36:23

Yeah. And I think if it’s using AI to do something that’s crazy and fun that you wouldn’t have a person do anyway, then go for it. But again, those are thoughtful, intentional ways to use AI. Like for example, we just did used AI to like put a tattoo of a brand on someone. We didn’t replace a person.

We weren’t going to pay a creator to get a tattoo of a brand logo on their arm. Like that’s, that would be cool. But you know, so I think like, people know that that’s a joke. They expect that it would be AI. We’re not trying to pull one over on them. 

 I think to that point also, CJ, I taught me if I’m rambling, but to that point also trust and authenticity is a brand’s biggest asset when it comes to social media and maybe potentially in general. Right. This is we’re talking about CPG, food and beverage and maybe beauty. We’re talking about things that you put on your face, put in your body. We want the quality to be good. 

 We want people to trust the story. If we’re talking about real food, especially, which is a big trend that we’re seeing at fancy food this year, then we want to emphasize that this is true. We’re not trying to trick you. We’re not trying to convince you that something is real. That’s not you know, we’re not trying to put an AI model in front of you. 

 We’re really speaking to you directly. That’s why you see brands that are doing really well are doing a lot of in real life content creation. They’re the ones doing content that’s like with a group of people and or, you know, capturing content at a party or doing a combination of experiential and content capture for the brand, right? Like leisure hydration is doing a great job. You see all of these examples like we do a lot of Wonder Juice stuff of like man on the street content. 

 That’s what’s performing. And I think that that push is in part because people are really tired of looking at one person behind the screen that still works. But in a post-COVID world, people are craving that in real life experience. And so seeing content of brands that are doing that kind of thing really speaks to people. But also they know it’s not AI, right? 

 It’s a lot harder to have an AI video of real people in a crowd on Venice Beach, drinking a beverage or eating a snack, than it is having like a, a single model drinking your product and have a look. Perfect and a perfect lifestyle setting.

CJ Bruce: 39:09

Yeah, yeah. It’s interesting. We’ve seen some of that content too, like with, with Sumo Citrus, we’ve done a lot of like man on the street person on the street content and and the. And even if, by the way, that with big fans.

Jessyca Dewey: 39:25

Big fan. But also like it’s not Sumo Citrus season. And that makes me really sad.

CJ Bruce: 39:29

It’s not I know, I know that’s part of the, you know, the built in demand. Yeah. But the in addition to yeah, it being hard to structure the way that it looks, I think also another thing that you get out of that is these authentic responses to people, right? An unexpected things that AI is very bad at that. Right?

It’s like it’s absolutely predicting the next thing that’s coming. So when somebody actually tastes something or has a brand experience and it’s a real reaction, people can tell and resonate more with that for sure.

Jessyca Dewey: 39:58

Yeah. And I mean, it spurs the creative process, right? Like, it’s so much more fun to hear what a random passerby has to say about a product. And then that how much content does that inspire from my team? You know, a ton to answer the question, right?

Like they can come back and say, oh, a lot of the people on the street said this, this, this and this, and we can use that as a feedback loop as well to create content. So that’s something that’s exciting about real people, turns out.

Building Creator Community Through Y Days

CJ Bruce: 40:28

Yeah. And definitely just, I think I agree this, this push toward more real life and all of that as a part of the backlash here and opportunities, I mean, like you’re saying a lot of opportunities for brands to just lean into that and figure out what that means for them. I want to just look ahead at, you know, with Y Collective. We talked a lot about the history of the past. What are you excited about now? Like what’s coming up? What’s, you know, what’s new and exciting for the collective?

Jessyca Dewey: 40:57

I’m glad you asked. We are about six weeks away from launching something that I’m so excited about. We are launching what we’re calling Y Days. Y. It’s a play on the Y Collective.

It’s created by the Y Collective, and it’s to serve primarily a lot of the clients of the Y Collective. But also really it’s to give back to our creator community. We have about 25 UGC content creators, and that number is always growing. And we have identified a gap in a community and skill set building. So we are working on a once a month Friday content creation community gathered sponsored gathering sponsored by the Y Collective, and we’re really looking forward to it. 

 So if you have any LA based content creators, what we’ll be doing is offering a setup and setting and equipment for the day scenes and guidance for the day trends and seasonal shooting. So for example, while we’re still working on the theme for the first one, we’ll be doing like a Friendsgiving theme and setting up that in real life experience with content creators who are looking to learn and work together to create content. And we’ll provide all the refreshments. We’ll provide the setting, whether it’s, you know, a nice big backyard with a Friendsgiving Tablescape or organizing a hike. We’re going to be looking at doing workshops with some industry professionals so that content creators who are looking to develop their skills will have access to learning with different equipment and so on and so forth, so that we can really give back to the the greater LA creator community and help raise up their skills, while also having the Y Collective team get together in person to create content as a group. So really excited about that. Cool.

CJ Bruce: 42:50

That’s cool. I love that idea.

Jessyca Dewey: 42:53

Thanks.

CJ Bruce: 42:54

All right. In that note, we’re we will wrap it up. But before we close, I want to make sure we point people to the right place to connect with you. So point people to your website for sure. And that’s ycollectiveagency.com, just the letter ycollectiveagency.com. Is there anywhere else that you would recommend people to connect with you or the agency?

Jessyca Dewey: 43:15

Sure. I mean, you can follow us on Instagram. We’re at why the letter? ycollectiveagency on Instagram. And then I am Jessyca JESSYCA.

That’s actually the origin of the Y Collective name JESSYCA with a Y on Instagram. So always playing on the Y in my name and the why in my purpose. So find us there JESSYCA with a Y or at ycollectiveagency.com. It’s Instagram. But yeah, looking forward to seeing some new faces if you want to give us a follow.

CJ Bruce: 43:56

Awesome. Jessyca, thanks so much for being on the show.

Jessyca Dewey: 43:58

Awesome. Thank you, CJ.

Outro: 44:01

Thanks for listening to The Missing Ingredient podcast. We’ll see you again next time. And be sure to click subscribe to get future episodes.